Homeless Man Maintains Tradition as Tombs Tumble
By Russell Nichols
NYT Institute

NEW ORLEANS, May 25 – As he shuffled across St. Louis Street in his gritty gray mechanic’s suit, tattered, blue Rain Vodka hat and a beaded crucifix, Arthur Raymond Smith was cordially acknowledged by residents who have grown accustomed to his visits to St. Louis Cemetery Number One.

The cemetery consists of bland, off-white standing tombs and a wall of vaults. The 71-year-old may be observed kneeling in front of a dark blue, lavender and red vault plastered with newspaper clippings and strewn with necklaces, stones and various other personal artifacts. He is the sole and devoted caretaker of his family’s tombs.

Arthur Raymond Smith
The cemetery consists of bland, off-white standing tombs and a wall of vaults. The 71-year-old may be observed kneeling in front of a dark blue, lavender and red vault plastered with newspaper clippings and strewn with necklaces, stones and various other personal artifacts. He is the sole and devoted caretaker of his family’s tombs.

At this cemetery and others in the area, Smith uses paints, petals and pearls to bring his family’s burial sites to life.

“I try to decorate to keep in with the season,” Smith said, stroking his ashen beard. “I just wanted to do something to their memory.”

Smith, who was born and raised in New Orleans, saw his grandmother, cousin and two uncles placed into the same vault. He said that in 1927, his grandfather was the first to be buried in the three-story wall vault that his grandmother purchased for $45.

New Orleans’ system of Multiple Internment allows for an infinite number of bodies in one tomb. But, the city prohibits opening the tomb for at least one year after a burial. Residents are allowed, however, to lease a wall vault to store bodies for at least one year and a day. Then, they have the option to move the bodies into the family’s free-standing tomb.

Although Smith preserves his family’s tomb, it, like the others in New Orleans cemeteries, is a victim of geography.

New Orleans, bordered by the Mississippi River and on the coast of the Gulf of Mexico, is between four and 16 feet below sea level at various points. This geological bowl formation, coupled with the 72 inches of annual rainfall, is responsible for the city’s high water table. In the past, this has caused buried wooden caskets to float to the surface, leading to unsanitary conditions.

The above-ground tomb was the only practical option, yet far from the perfect solution.

Atmospheric weathering has caused warping, or bowing, and erosion, or “sugaring,” of the tomb surfaces. Also, the city’s volatile thermal cycle has caused many marble-clad tombs to expand and eventually crack.

In St. Louis Number One cemetery, the pebbled road snakes around the sun-washed monuments of crumbling bricks and peeling stucco. Some are adorned with tarnished, crooked crosses and marble tablets, overlooked by praying archangels. Others are outlined with ironwork gates rusted red from acidic rain.

St. Louis Number One, built in 1789, is the oldest cemetery in New Orleans. While some tombs are 250 years old and standing firm, others are in a state of disrepair.

Though some residents, like Smith, have maintained the vaults they own, restoration organizations are dedicated to restructuring tombs that are not maintained on a regular basis.

Save Our Cemeteries, a local nonprofit organization founded in 1974, has raised millions of dollars in an effort to repair and restore decrepit vaults.

Louise Saenz, executive director of the organization, is in charge of determining the state of the tomb and how to repair it.

“We bring out an architectural conservator to assess the overall integrity of the tomb,” Saenz said. “Then we do background research to determine the original construction.”

But SOC has done more than coordinate with architectural conservators. The organization, which has approximately 800 members, initiates programs, organizes cemetery clean-up events, hosts lectures and circulates a newsletter to inform residents about the growing problem. SOC-sponsored tours of the cemeteries attract a wide range of residents and tourists, with proceeds benefiting the organization.

“We are dedicated to restoration, preservation and education,” Saenz said.

With an annual budget of about $200,000 from donations, grants and fundraisers, SOC has developed a large clientele and its efforts have spawned architectural conservator firms such as Monumental Restorations Company and Chaux Vive.

Chaux Vive, which means “quick lime” in French, is an independent firm that specializes in preservation services and historic architectural conservation.

Laura Ewen, co-owner of Chaux Vive, was a conservation assistant for the 2002 SOC project that resulted in the restoration and stabilization of about 60 tombs. Along with the conservation assistants, a stone carver, a blacksmith, a metal worker and a plasterer chipped in to restore the tombs wounded by weather and time.

Ewen said she did a lot of hands-on work, including repainting the black iron gates, patching plaster and filling cracks. She said corrosion results from a chain reaction: when the stucco becomes loose, roots and vegetation start to protrude through the cracks and cause the mortar to fracture, eventually stripping the tomb to its brick core.

“If you don’t keep up cyclical maintenance, small deterioration leads to big problems,” Ewen said.

But she also said the most significant aspect of the project was its attempt to restore the cemetery to its original appearance.

“We used material consistent with the historic material such as the lime wash colors,” Ewen said.

SOC has referred many families to Chaux Vive and has contacted them for various preservation projects.

Lindsay Hannah, one of the three partners at Chaux Vive, earned her graduate degree in historic preservation from the University of Pennsylvania and started the firm with Ewen and Heather Knight about one and a half years ago.

She said tomb restoration is a multi-step process that can take weeks or months, depending on weather conditions.

First, the conservators start by cleaning the tomb, scrubbing it to remove loose stucco. Then, they patch it with a lime-based mortar. They clean the marble statue or tablet and put on a new coat of stucco before administering the lime wash.

Hannah said that although the company is still in its infancy, its reputation has been expanding and it receives about five or six restoration requests a month from families who want to reuse their tombs or pay homage to the deceased.

The condition of the cemeteries has garnered so much attention that on Feb. 27, a national foundation contacted SOC to organize a clean-up day at St. Louis Number One.

The Travelers Conservation Foundation, a group established in 1989 by the U.S. Tour Operators Association, came to New Orleans and restored more than 50 tombs. Bruce Beckham, executive director of TCF, said the local conservators taught 300 volunteers how to scrub, paint and wash.

Beckham said that while some tombs were salvageable, others were so rundown that they could not be restored.

The City of New Orleans operates seven cemeteries and had a budget of about $290,000 in 2003. The remainder of the cemeteries, named after Catholic saints, are operated by the Archdiocese of New Orleans.

Michael Boudreaux, director of cemeteries for the Archdiocese of New Orleans, said the maintenance of the tombs becomes difficult to oversee when there are no records of the owners.

“Families have passed on or moved away,” said Boudreaux, who has been working for cemeteries for 36 years. “About 90 percent of the tombs do not have a contact person.”

Boudreaux coordinates with field directors and the superintendent at each location to help them with finance and management, but he said restoration work is contingent upon the donations and grants the archdiocese receives. Also, the tomb’s perpetual care is at the discretion of the contact person or persons.

“We work in an advisory capacity,” he said.

But the archdiocese and the city of New Orleans can only do so much. The tombs are still in perpetual war against the elements.

Smith said he remembers his family’s vault steadily succumbing to gravity due to the water table.

“It kept sinking inches at a time,” Smith said. “It’s so old.”

But he said the sinking has slowed.

Smith, standing at his mother’s gravesite – garlanded with stuffed animals, flowers and multicolored streamers – at Green Street Cemetery, said he will never forget his mother and the lessons she engrained in him – chiefly resilience.

Smith said when his mother died, he visited her gravesite every day and, although he doesn’t go as often, he takes the time out to acknowledge her in prayer.

“I miss that closeness me and my mother had,” said Smith, an only child. “I’ve had a broken heart for the last 25 years.”

His mother died of diabetes in 1979 and Smith said he brings water to her gravesite so “her spirit will never thirst.”

Smith has no children and no living immediate relatives, but often goes to St. Louis Cathedral to commune with his ancestors and said he brings flowers to the gravesites on all special occasions.

Although the erratic atmospheric conditions have advanced the dilapidation of many tombs, Smith is determined not to let these unpredictable floods drown his family’s legacy.

While organizations like SOC are dedicated to preserving the monuments, Smith said he is dedicated to preserving the moments.

The material on this Web page was produced by student journalists selected by and working under the supervision of staff members of The New York Times, The Boston Globe and regional newspapers of The New York Times Co.



Editors of any newspaper or news agency are permitted to use any material on this site free of charge. They are requested to credit the responsible student reporter or photographer.